Traditional Scottish Clootie Dumpling
A Pudding from the Old Kitchen
There are some recipes that feel like they’ve always existed, passed quietly from one kitchen to the next. Clootie dumpling is one of them. Dense, gently spiced, and studded with fruit, this traditional Scottish pudding was never about show – it was about warmth, thrift, and feeding the people you loved.
Here at One Plate Please, we celebrate food with a story, and few dishes tell a better one than this traditional Scottish clootie dumpling. Cooked slowly in a cloth and finished in the oven, it’s comfort food in its purest form. It’s not a traditional dish but is often enjoyed during the festive season. And is there a season more festive than Christmas?
A Brief History of Clootie Dumpling
Long before recipe cards and fan ovens, clootie dumpling was bubbling away gently in kitchens across Scotland. Wrapped in a simple floured cloth – the cloot – and lowered into a pot of simmering water, this humble pudding was born from necessity, thrift, and the rhythms of rural life.
In farming communities and Highland homes, ingredients were precious and nothing went to waste. Flour, suet, dried fruit, spices, and the occasional apple from the store cupboard were mixed together to create a filling dessert that could feed a family and last for days. Before ovens became commonplace, boiling puddings in cloths was the most reliable way to bake, and clootie dumpling became a much-loved staple of the Scottish table.
But clootie dumpling was never just about sustenance. It was – and still is – a celebration pudding! Traditionally made for Hogmanay, weddings, and special family gatherings, it often carried charms hidden inside, echoing the customs of Scottish Christmas pudding. Each slice told a story of luck, prosperity, and shared moments around the table.
What truly sets a traditional clootie dumpling apart is its finish. Once unwrapped, the dumpling is placed in a hot oven to dry, forming a lightly crusted skin — a tell-tale sign of an authentic version. That contrast between the firm outer layer and the soft, spiced interior is what makes clootie dumpling so distinctive.
Here at One Plate Please, this is exactly the kind of food we love – honest, comforting, and deeply connected to the past. Clootie dumpling is more than a recipe; it’s a reminder of slower cooking, shared meals, and traditions passed down one generation at a time.
What is Suet?
Suet is the hard, white fat found around the kidneys of beef or mutton. In traditional British and Scottish cooking, it has long been prized for baking and puddings because it melts slowly and evenly, giving dishes a rich flavour and a light, tender texture.
Unlike butter, suet stays firm when mixed into dough, which helps create the distinctive crumb found in classic recipes like the clootie dumpling. When cooked, it melts gently, keeping puddings moist without making them greasy.
Today, suet is sold either fresh or shredded (often coated lightly in flour to prevent clumping). Vegetarian suet alternatives are also available, though traditional recipes rely on beef suet for their authentic taste and texture. A suitable kitchen alternative to the suet is shredded cold butter.
In short, suet is an old-fashioned ingredient that plays a quiet but essential role in many of Scotland’s most comforting dishes.
How to make the Clootie Dumpling?
Step 1: Make the Dough
In a large bowl, sift all-purpose flour along with the baking powder, mixed spice, ground cinnamon, ground nutmeg and salt. Add suet and with clean dry fingers, rub-in the flour and suet together for a few minutes until all the ingredients combine well into a breadcrumbs like texture. Add the sugar and give a good mix.
Follow this with the raisins, sultanas, currants and chopped dates and gently fold into the flour-suet mix, followed by a grated apple. Mix all the ingredients well until the flour coats them. Beat a couple of eggs, add to the dough and mix well. Add some breadcrumbs, dark treacle and milk and fold in all the ingredients together until they come together as a thick sticky dough. Roughly shape the dough into a ball and set aside
Step 2: Prepare the Cloot
Dip a muslin cloth (Cloot) in hot water and wring out all the excess water and spread the cloth on the kitchen countertop and dust it thoroughly with all-purpose flour leaving no gaps. (This flour forms the outer skin of the clootie dumpling)
Step 3: Wrap the Dumpling
Place the dough ball in the middle of the dusted Cloot. Dust the top of the dough ball with some flour. Bring together the four ends of the cloth over the doughball and with the help of a kitchen string, tie them up tightly, leaving no visible open gaps in the cloth. Do not knot the cloth tightly around the dough. leave some room inside for expansion of the dough as it cooks.
Step 4: Cook the Clootie Dumpling
Place an upside-down plate or trivet in the bottom of a large pot. Lower in the wrapped dumpling and cover with simmering water. Ensure that the water level is right upto the top of the dough ball. Cover the pot with a lid and cook on low flame for 3.5 hours. Top up with more water during the cooking process, if needed. Take the Dumpling out of the pot and transfer to a cooling rack. Once it cools down a bit, untie the cloth and slowly peel it off the dumpling.
Step 5: Skinning the Dumpling
Carefully transfer the dumpling to a baking tray. Bake it in a preheated oven at 180℃ for about 15 minutes till a thin crust develops around the Dumpling.
How to Serve Clootie Dumpling
- Cut the Dumpling into slices or wedges and serve it hot with some Vanilla custard
- If there are leftovers, slice them and fry them in butter and enjoy them for breakfast with some streaky bacon, honey butter and fresh berries
Clootie Dumpling
Equipment
- 1 Muslin cloth
- Kitchen string
- 1 Large pot with lid
- 1 Cooling rack
- 1 Large Baking Pan/ Tray
Ingredients
- 300 grams All-purpose flour
- 3 tsp Baking powder
- 1 tsp Mixed Spice
- ½ tsp Ground cinnamon
- ½ tsp Ground Nutmeg
- 1 tsp Salt
- 125 grams Suet mix, shredded. (substitute with cold, shredded unsalted butter)
- 90 grams Brown Sugar
- 75 grams Raisins
- 75 grams Sultanas
- 75 grams Currants
- 50 grams Dates (chopped)
- 1 whole Apple, large (peeled & grated)
- 2 pieces Eggs, large (beaten)
- 75 grams Breadcrumbs
- 2 tbsp Dark Treacle
- 150 ml Milk
Additional Ingredients:
- All-purpose flour (as needed – for dusting)
- Boiled Water (for cooking the dumpling)
Instructions
Making the Dough:
- In a large mixing bowl, sift the flour along with the baking powder, mixed spice, ground cinnamon, ground nutmeg and salt
- Add the suet and with clean dry fingers, rub-in the flour and suet together for a few minutes until all the ingredients combine well into a breadcrumbs like texture
- Add the sugar and give a good mix
- Follow this with the raisins, sultanas, currants and dates and gently fold into the flour-suet mix, followed by the grated apple. Mix all the ingredients well until the flour coats them
- Add the beaten eggs and mix well
- Add the breadcrumbs, dark treacle and milk and fold in all the ingredients together until they come together as a thick sticky dough
- Roughly shape the dough into a ball and set aside
Preparing the Cloot:
- Dip the muslin cloth in hot water and wring out all the excess water and spread the cloth(cloot)on the kitchen countertop and dust it thoroughly with all-purpose flour leaving no gaps. (This flour forms the outer skin of the clootie dumpling)
Wrapping the Dumpling:
- Place the dough ball in the middle of the dusted Cloot. Dust the top of the dough ball with some flour
- Bring together the four ends of the cloth over the doughball and with the help of a kitchen string, tie them up tightly, leaving no visible open gaps in the cloth
- Do not knot the cloth tightly around the dough. leave some room inside for expansion of the dough as it cooks.
Cooking the Dumpling:
- Place an upside-down plate or trivet in the bottom of a large pot. Lower in the wrapped dumpling and cover with simmering water
- Cover the pot with a lid and cook on low flame for 3.5 hours. Top up with more water during the cooking process, if needed.
- Take the Dumpling out of the pot and transfer to a cooling rack. Once it cools down a bit, untie the cloth and slowly peel it off the dumpling
Skinning the Dumpling:
- Carefully transfer the dumpling to a baking tray
- Bake it in a preheated oven at 180℃ for about 15 minutes till a thin crust develops around the Dumpling
Serving Suggestions:
- Cut the Dumpling into slices or wedges and serve it hot with some Vanilla custard
- If there are leftovers, slice them and fry them in butter and enjoy them for breakfast with some streaky bacon, honey butter and fresh berries
Notes
- Keeps well for several days
- Excellent sliced and fried in butter the next day
- Flavour improves after resting
If you tried this Recipe, leaving a comment below the post along with a star rating, will enable more readers and cooking enthusiasts to discover these recipes! Also, if you are on Instagram, do share a picture of the dish and tag @one_plate_please to be featured in my stories! Also do check out my other Christmas Specials!
Do follow me on Instagram , Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest.
Reach me by email at contact@oneplateplease.com